Even though the world is moving towards the digital world, most homes still feature a mailbox to receive paper documents such as bills, newsletters, magazines, and newspapers. This makes it an evergreen feature in each home regardless of their sizes and style.

So, if you are looking for a mailbox that is both aesthetically pleasing and durable, this review is written specifically for you. We formed a  team of experts to curate the list of the best mailboxes available in the market. And to have a more detailed perspective after this in-depth review, click on the buttons below to check out their best deals on Amazon.

Best Mailboxes Comparison & Rating

Mailboxes

Features

Mail Boss 7506 Mail Manager Curbside Locking Security Mailbox, Black,Large
  • patented anti-pry latch locking mechanism
  • innovative baffle door
  • 14 and 16-gauge galvanized welded steel construction
Architectural Mailboxes 6300B-10 Oasis 360 Locking Parcel Mailbox, Extra Large, Black
  • dual door locking parcel mailbox
  • rear and front locking system
  • magnetic intake door closure
Gibraltar Mailboxes Woodlands Medium Capacity Galvanized Steel Black, Wall-Mount Mailbox, L4010WB0,Textured Black
  • textured powder-coated finish
  • heavy-duty galvanized steel
  • covered hinges
Medium Rural Box Mail Storage Steel Gray - mailboxes for Outside - Large Mailbox.
  • single-wall galvanized steel construction
  • flap-style opening
  • mail indicator alerts
Locking Mailboxes Wall Mounted Vertical – Jssmst Key Lock Drop Mail Box Medium Capacity Galvanized Steel Cover Rust-Proof Metal Post Box, 12.6 x 8.5 x 3.4 Inch, Black, SM-0601L
  • key lock feature with 2 keys for security
  • powdered coated exterior finish
  • waterproof design

1. Mail Boss Mail Manager Curbside Locking Security Mailbox

Mail Boss 7506 Mail Manager Curbside Locking Security Mailbox, Black,Large
Specifications:
98% Overall

Brand

Mail Boss

Weight

22 pounds

Style

Curbside

Material

Galvanized Steel

98%
Design
98%
reliability
97%
Features
99%
Durability
Pros:
  • Consists of 14 and 16-gauge galvanized welded steel construction that defends against vandalism.
  • Includes an innovative baffle door that accepts small parcels, packages, and a box of checks and also deters fishing.
  • Provides ultimate mail security through its patented anti-pry latch locking mechanism.
  • Large capacity of 3-7 days worth of mail.
  • Heavy-duty galvanized steel for weather protection.
  • Includes a concealed outgoing mail clip, 3 keys, and installation hardware.
  • Equipped with stainless steel hinges for ease of use.
Cons:
  • Can be challenging to clean, especially on the inside. However, a cleaning brush to aid the cleaning process can do the trick.
  • A bit pricey. Nonetheless, the price is justified with its state-of-the-art security features.
Final Take:

With its large capacity of around 3 to 7 days’ worth of mail, the Mail Boss is definitely something you want for your front lawn. It can carry letters and heavy books, magazines, and newsletters. Also, it can protect your items from harsh weather because of its thick galvanized steel exterior. Plus, it is equipped with a patented anti-pry latch lock to ensure 100% mail security.

2. Architectural Mailboxes Oasis 360 Locking Parcel Mailbox

Architectural Mailboxes 6300B-10 Oasis 360 Locking Parcel Mailbox, Extra Large, Black
Specifications:
97% Overall

Brand

Architectural Mailboxes

Weight

13.72 pounds

Style

Post Mount

Material

Aluminum, Galvanized Steel

96%
Design
97%
reliability
98%
Features
95%
Durability
Pros:
  • Consists of a dual door locking parcel mailbox with two doors for easy access.
  • Pre-drilled 4 inches x 10 inches mounting that allows easy installation.
  • Made from galvanized steel construction that is thoroughly powder-coated inside and out for added corrosion resistance.
  • Protects mail bundles, small parcels, and thick envelopes.
  • Features a magnetic intake door closure.
  • Comes with a rear and front locking system with 4 keys.
Cons:
  • The hardware and mounting bracket are required to mount to posts. Nonetheless, they are readily available via Amazon and other online selling platforms.
Final Take:

For those who prefer both style and function, the Oasis 360 mailboxes offer both! Its sleek and sophisticated style will make your front lawn stand out without compromising the security quality of your mail. Also, it is designed with two retrieval doors for front and back access. Besides that, the rear door allows the homeowner to retrieve mail with ease and safety. Built with a cast aluminum front frame that envelops the door along with a heavy-duty locking mechanism for added durability, this mailbox is highly recommended for residential owners!

3. Gibraltar Mailboxes Woodlands Wall Mount Mailbox

Gibraltar Mailboxes Woodlands Medium Capacity Galvanized Steel Black, Wall-Mount Mailbox, L4010WB0,Textured Black
Specifications:
95% Overall

Brand

Solar Group

Weight

4.4 pounds

Style

Wall Mount

Material

Steel

94%
Design
95%
reliability
95%
Features
94%
Durability
Pros:
  • Consists of a textured powder-coated finish that is rust-resistant.
  • Clean and modern design offers aesthetics and space for address numbers.
  • Made from heavy-duty galvanized steel for added durability.
  • Mailbox comes fully assembled, and a cut-out template is included for fast and easy installation.
  • Consists of a covered hinge that does not scratch the paint off walls.
Cons:
  • The mounting hardware is sold separately.
  • Its medium size can hold reasonable-weighted items, but not heavyweight items such as thick books.
Final Take:

For individuals who want to have a hassle-free assembly experience for mailboxes, the Gibraltar mailboxes is the way to go! This is shipped to you already pre-assembled with cut-out templates for a fast and easy installation. At 4.4 pounds, this mailbox is sleek steel and a perfect addition to your front lawn. It does not only come in a rust-resistant finish but is made from heavy-duty galvanized steel for added durability. This definitely is worth your money!

4. Rural Box Steel Storage Mailbox

Medium Rural Box Mail Storage Steel Gray - mailboxes for Outside - Large Mailbox.
Specifications:
92% Overall

Brand

ShoppingOnBed

Weight

4 pounds

Style

Post Mount

Material

Steel

90%
Design
93%
reliability
92%
Features
93%
Durability
Pros:
  • Features a single-wall galvanized steel construction that resists rust for durability and is ideal for rural use.
  • The flap-style opening provides easy access to the contents, and the mail indicator alerts your carrier when you have outgoing items.
  • Mail indicator alerts postal carriers to outgoing items.
  • Quick and easy installation with minor assembly required.
  • Has the capacity to carry small to medium-sized parcels and packages.
Cons:
  • Mounting brackets and hardware are sold separately.
  • Some of the pieces are made out of plastic, which can be an issue for some consumers who prefer steel pieces. However, this does not affect the durability of the product.
Final Take:

Individuals who want a cost-efficient mailbox that does their job should look into the Rural Box Steel Storage Mailbox! Why? It offers both quality and affordability. With its capacity to carry small to medium-sized parcels, it is perfect for residential use. A bonus feature of this mailbox is its Mail Indicator, which alerts postal carriers to outgoing items. Besides featuring a flap-style opening that provides easy access to your mail, it also is constructed with galvanized steel to resist corrosion and fading.

5. Jssmst Key Lock Drop Mailbox

Locking Mailboxes Wall Mounted Vertical – Jssmst Key Lock Drop Mail Box Medium Capacity Galvanized Steel Cover Rust-Proof Metal Post Box, 12.6 x 8.5 x 3.4 Inch, Black, SM-0601L
Specifications:
91% Overall

Brand

Jssmst

Weight

3.01 pounds

Style

Wall Mount

Material

Metal

92%
Design
90%
reliability
92%
Features
90%
Durability
Pros:
  • Has a large capacity and can hold magazines and large envelopes. It is able to hold days worth of mail at a time.
  • For its security features, it includes a key lock feature with 2 keys for security against theft.
  • Crafted with quality galvanized steel for strength and durability.
  • Features a powdered coated exterior finish to withstand wear and tear.
  • The mailbox includes pre-drilled holes, mounting screws, and an instruction manual for easy installation.
  • Has a waterproof design which protects mail and parcels from harsh weather.
Cons:
  • Numbers and letters for mailbox customization and design are sold separately.
Final Take:

For anyone looking for a perfectly-sized, aesthetically pleasing, and security-imbibed mailbox, go for the Jssmst Key lock drop mailbox! The password set-up is flawless, and its quality steel material also ensures that your mail remains dry and water-free! If you have any trouble with your mailbox, their friendly customer support is available through multiple channels 24/7. Lastly, it includes two keys for added security and a powdered coated exterior finish that ensures durability and strength.

Best Mailboxes - Buyer's Guide

security

Security is the number one priority for people who are thinking of buying a mailbox. Ensure that the mailbox you buy has security features such as locks or passwords that will protect you from identity theft or nosy neighbors who want to look through your mail.

durability

Since most mailboxes are located outside where they are exposed to harsh weather, make sure that your mailbox is equipped with only the best quality material, such as steel and a powdered-coated exterior finish. In this manner, you are ensured that your mailbox is rust-resistant, corrosion-resistant, and will last for a long time.

aesthetic

One of the first things people will see when they visit your home is your mailbox since it’s located in front. Making sure that your mailbox matches the aesthetic and style of your house is definitely a must.

capacity

Depending on the amount of mail and parcels you get every day, you have to make sure to buy a mailbox that can hold the right amount of packages you are expecting to receive.

reputable manufacturer

To make sure that the mailbox you purchase is of good quality, do a background check on the mailbox manufacturer. A good mailbox manufacturer must show longevity in the market for at least 20 years. The longer they have been in the industry, the better and trusted their products are. Plus, you can check for their online reputation and articles like this to narrow down your search.

Best Mailboxes - FAQs

What is the difference between walk-up or curbside delivery?

The difference between walk-up or curbside delivery is as follows:


Walk-up Mail Delivery - If you prefer that postal carriers deliver your mail to your door, consider buying a wall mount or mailbox slot-style mailboxes.


Curbside Mail Delivery - If you prefer that postal carriers leave your mail at your gate, you can opt to purchase a post-mount, column mount, or a pedestal locking mailbox.

How will your new mailbox be installed?

There are three ways for mailboxes to be installed. They are:

Surface Mounted - This is ideal for apartment complexes where many tenants get mail in one building. This is where the mailbox is mounted onto a wall.

Recessed Mounted - For universities or offices where there is a person in charge of distributing mail, you can consider installing it through the recessed mounted type, provided that there is a security measure for the mail.

Pedestal Mounted - For apartment buildings with a manageable number of tenants, they can consider installing their mailbox through the pedestal mounted type.

Does style and aesthetic matter when it comes to purchasing a mailbox?

It depends! Some users look at the mailbox’s durability, while some customers prefer that their mailbox matches their home’s look and feel. What matters is your mail’s safety and security. This should be the first and foremost feature you have to check when purchasing a mailbox.

What is the best material for a mailbox?

Steel and stainless steel are the most durable materials used for a mailbox. Likewise, these materials are also resistant to rust and can withstand harsh sunlight and the heavy onslaught of rain.

Author